Coincident Entities and Question-Begging Predicates: an Issue in Meta-Ontology View Full Text


Ontology type: schema:ScholarlyArticle      Open Access: True


Article Info

DATE

2013-04

AUTHORS

Francesco Berto

ABSTRACT

Meta-ontology (in van Inwagen's sense) concerns the methodology of ontology, and a controversial meta-ontological issue is to what extent ontology can rely on linguistic analysis while establishing the furniture of the world. This paper discusses an argument advanced by some ontologists (I call them unifiers) against supporters of or coincident entities (I call them multipliers) and its meta-ontological import. Multipliers resort to Leibniz's Law to establish that spatiotemporally coincident entities a and b are distinct, by pointing at a predicate F() made true by a and false by b. Unifiers try to put multipliers in front of a dilemma: in attempting to introduce metaphysical differences on the basis of semantic distinctions, multipliers either (a) rest on a fallacy of verbalism, entailed by a trade-off between a de dicto and a de re reading of modal claims, or (b) beg the question against unifiers by having to assume the distinction between a and b beforehand. I shall rise a tu quoque, showing that unifiers couldn't even distinguish material objects (or events) from the spatiotemporal regions they occupy unless they also resorted to linguistic distinctions. Their methodological aim to emancipate themselves from linguistic analysis in ontological businesses is therefore problematic. More... »

PAGES

1-15

References to SciGraph publications

  • 2002. Words and Objects in INDIVIDUALS, ESSENCE AND IDENTITY
  • 1975-05. Contingent identity in JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHICAL LOGIC
  • Journal

    TITLE

    Metaphysica

    ISSUE

    1

    VOLUME

    14

    Author Affiliations

    Identifiers

    URI

    http://scigraph.springernature.com/pub.10.1007/s12133-012-0106-x

    DOI

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s12133-012-0106-x

    DIMENSIONS

    https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1039875880


    Indexing Status Check whether this publication has been indexed by Scopus and Web Of Science using the SN Indexing Status Tool
    Incoming Citations Browse incoming citations for this publication using opencitations.net

    JSON-LD is the canonical representation for SciGraph data.

    TIP: You can open this SciGraph record using an external JSON-LD service: JSON-LD Playground Google SDTT

    [
      {
        "@context": "https://springernature.github.io/scigraph/jsonld/sgcontext.json", 
        "about": [
          {
            "id": "http://purl.org/au-research/vocabulary/anzsrc-for/2008/2004", 
            "inDefinedTermSet": "http://purl.org/au-research/vocabulary/anzsrc-for/2008/", 
            "name": "Linguistics", 
            "type": "DefinedTerm"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "http://purl.org/au-research/vocabulary/anzsrc-for/2008/20", 
            "inDefinedTermSet": "http://purl.org/au-research/vocabulary/anzsrc-for/2008/", 
            "name": "Language, Communication and Culture", 
            "type": "DefinedTerm"
          }
        ], 
        "author": [
          {
            "affiliation": {
              "alternateName": "University of Aberdeen", 
              "id": "https://www.grid.ac/institutes/grid.7107.1", 
              "name": [
                "Department of Philosophy and Northern Institute of Philosophy, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, UK"
              ], 
              "type": "Organization"
            }, 
            "familyName": "Berto", 
            "givenName": "Francesco", 
            "id": "sg:person.016556532267.89", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/discover/publication?and_facet_researcher=ur.016556532267.89"
            ], 
            "type": "Person"
          }
        ], 
        "citation": [
          {
            "id": "sg:pub.10.1007/bf00693273", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1008754965", 
              "https://doi.org/10.1007/bf00693273"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "sg:pub.10.1007/bf00693273", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1008754965", 
              "https://doi.org/10.1007/bf00693273"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.1080/00048408512341901", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1018084504"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203221303", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1022479024"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "sg:pub.10.1007/978-94-017-1866-0_2", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1037971038", 
              "https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-017-1866-0_2"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1746-8361.2000.tb00286.x", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1038462270"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.1111/0029-4624.00133", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1042814386"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.1111/0029-4624.00133", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1042814386"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.1111/0029-4624.00094", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1049926227"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9213.00233", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1050625654"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.1093/analys/48.4.221", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1059387902"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.1093/analys/52.1.12", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1059388074"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.1093/analys/57.1.1", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1059388327"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.1093/mind/101.401.89", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1059880078"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.1093/mind/112.446.195", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1059880993"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.2307/2026781", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1069704825"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.2307/2183184", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1069812564"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.2307/2185716", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1069814689"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.2307/2214398", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1069830704"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.2307/2219592", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1069834998"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.2307/2564596", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1069992958"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.2307/2653562", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1070046441"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.2307/2940887", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1070140511"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.2307/2940990", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1070140550"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.2307/3328504", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1070267214"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.5840/monist200083315", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1073215605"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }, 
          {
            "id": "https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511612756", 
            "sameAs": [
              "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1098730823"
            ], 
            "type": "CreativeWork"
          }
        ], 
        "datePublished": "2013-04", 
        "datePublishedReg": "2013-04-01", 
        "description": "Meta-ontology (in van Inwagen's sense) concerns the methodology of ontology, and a controversial meta-ontological issue is to what extent ontology can rely on linguistic analysis while establishing the furniture of the world. This paper discusses an argument advanced by some ontologists (I call them unifiers) against supporters of or coincident entities (I call them multipliers) and its meta-ontological import. Multipliers resort to Leibniz's Law to establish that spatiotemporally coincident entities a and b are distinct, by pointing at a predicate F() made true by a and false by b. Unifiers try to put multipliers in front of a dilemma: in attempting to introduce metaphysical differences on the basis of semantic distinctions, multipliers either (a) rest on a fallacy of verbalism, entailed by a trade-off between a de dicto and a de re reading of modal claims, or (b) beg the question against unifiers by having to assume the distinction between a and b beforehand. I shall rise a tu quoque, showing that unifiers couldn't even distinguish material objects (or events) from the spatiotemporal regions they occupy unless they also resorted to linguistic distinctions. Their methodological aim to emancipate themselves from linguistic analysis in ontological businesses is therefore problematic.", 
        "genre": "research_article", 
        "id": "sg:pub.10.1007/s12133-012-0106-x", 
        "inLanguage": [
          "en"
        ], 
        "isAccessibleForFree": true, 
        "isPartOf": [
          {
            "id": "sg:journal.1145333", 
            "issn": [
              "1437-2053", 
              "1874-6373"
            ], 
            "name": "Metaphysica", 
            "type": "Periodical"
          }, 
          {
            "issueNumber": "1", 
            "type": "PublicationIssue"
          }, 
          {
            "type": "PublicationVolume", 
            "volumeNumber": "14"
          }
        ], 
        "name": "Coincident Entities and Question-Begging Predicates: an Issue in Meta-Ontology", 
        "pagination": "1-15", 
        "productId": [
          {
            "name": "readcube_id", 
            "type": "PropertyValue", 
            "value": [
              "bdf376316c39e9f4f3ea6a8fa998e474fdb831e5d3d54e0465f7c1f188780243"
            ]
          }, 
          {
            "name": "doi", 
            "type": "PropertyValue", 
            "value": [
              "10.1007/s12133-012-0106-x"
            ]
          }, 
          {
            "name": "dimensions_id", 
            "type": "PropertyValue", 
            "value": [
              "pub.1039875880"
            ]
          }
        ], 
        "sameAs": [
          "https://doi.org/10.1007/s12133-012-0106-x", 
          "https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1039875880"
        ], 
        "sdDataset": "articles", 
        "sdDatePublished": "2019-04-10T21:39", 
        "sdLicense": "https://scigraph.springernature.com/explorer/license/", 
        "sdPublisher": {
          "name": "Springer Nature - SN SciGraph project", 
          "type": "Organization"
        }, 
        "sdSource": "s3://com-uberresearch-data-dimensions-target-20181106-alternative/cleanup/v134/2549eaecd7973599484d7c17b260dba0a4ecb94b/merge/v9/a6c9fde33151104705d4d7ff012ea9563521a3ce/jats-lookup/v90/0000000001_0000000264/records_8687_00000523.jsonl", 
        "type": "ScholarlyArticle", 
        "url": "http://link.springer.com/10.1007%2Fs12133-012-0106-x"
      }
    ]
     

    Download the RDF metadata as:  json-ld nt turtle xml License info

    HOW TO GET THIS DATA PROGRAMMATICALLY:

    JSON-LD is a popular format for linked data which is fully compatible with JSON.

    curl -H 'Accept: application/ld+json' 'https://scigraph.springernature.com/pub.10.1007/s12133-012-0106-x'

    N-Triples is a line-based linked data format ideal for batch operations.

    curl -H 'Accept: application/n-triples' 'https://scigraph.springernature.com/pub.10.1007/s12133-012-0106-x'

    Turtle is a human-readable linked data format.

    curl -H 'Accept: text/turtle' 'https://scigraph.springernature.com/pub.10.1007/s12133-012-0106-x'

    RDF/XML is a standard XML format for linked data.

    curl -H 'Accept: application/rdf+xml' 'https://scigraph.springernature.com/pub.10.1007/s12133-012-0106-x'


     

    This table displays all metadata directly associated to this object as RDF triples.

    138 TRIPLES      21 PREDICATES      52 URIs      19 LITERALS      7 BLANK NODES

    Subject Predicate Object
    1 sg:pub.10.1007/s12133-012-0106-x schema:about anzsrc-for:20
    2 anzsrc-for:2004
    3 schema:author N77bd6416f34f48b1a8998a20a77a8629
    4 schema:citation sg:pub.10.1007/978-94-017-1866-0_2
    5 sg:pub.10.1007/bf00693273
    6 https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511612756
    7 https://doi.org/10.1080/00048408512341901
    8 https://doi.org/10.1093/analys/48.4.221
    9 https://doi.org/10.1093/analys/52.1.12
    10 https://doi.org/10.1093/analys/57.1.1
    11 https://doi.org/10.1093/mind/101.401.89
    12 https://doi.org/10.1093/mind/112.446.195
    13 https://doi.org/10.1111/0029-4624.00094
    14 https://doi.org/10.1111/0029-4624.00133
    15 https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9213.00233
    16 https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1746-8361.2000.tb00286.x
    17 https://doi.org/10.2307/2026781
    18 https://doi.org/10.2307/2183184
    19 https://doi.org/10.2307/2185716
    20 https://doi.org/10.2307/2214398
    21 https://doi.org/10.2307/2219592
    22 https://doi.org/10.2307/2564596
    23 https://doi.org/10.2307/2653562
    24 https://doi.org/10.2307/2940887
    25 https://doi.org/10.2307/2940990
    26 https://doi.org/10.2307/3328504
    27 https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203221303
    28 https://doi.org/10.5840/monist200083315
    29 schema:datePublished 2013-04
    30 schema:datePublishedReg 2013-04-01
    31 schema:description Meta-ontology (in van Inwagen's sense) concerns the methodology of ontology, and a controversial meta-ontological issue is to what extent ontology can rely on linguistic analysis while establishing the furniture of the world. This paper discusses an argument advanced by some ontologists (I call them unifiers) against supporters of or coincident entities (I call them multipliers) and its meta-ontological import. Multipliers resort to Leibniz's Law to establish that spatiotemporally coincident entities a and b are distinct, by pointing at a predicate F() made true by a and false by b. Unifiers try to put multipliers in front of a dilemma: in attempting to introduce metaphysical differences on the basis of semantic distinctions, multipliers either (a) rest on a fallacy of verbalism, entailed by a trade-off between a de dicto and a de re reading of modal claims, or (b) beg the question against unifiers by having to assume the distinction between a and b beforehand. I shall rise a tu quoque, showing that unifiers couldn't even distinguish material objects (or events) from the spatiotemporal regions they occupy unless they also resorted to linguistic distinctions. Their methodological aim to emancipate themselves from linguistic analysis in ontological businesses is therefore problematic.
    32 schema:genre research_article
    33 schema:inLanguage en
    34 schema:isAccessibleForFree true
    35 schema:isPartOf N671858891f6e438a8053ae728032614a
    36 Nffaacf46489a4ca1816cd69414d2532a
    37 sg:journal.1145333
    38 schema:name Coincident Entities and Question-Begging Predicates: an Issue in Meta-Ontology
    39 schema:pagination 1-15
    40 schema:productId N21a387bd16784252be3b43b643f48a9c
    41 N65398d13ee804b27b7824aadf9e9bb2d
    42 Nfe5f41cab9134f0ca4ce7f83038e2f6b
    43 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1039875880
    44 https://doi.org/10.1007/s12133-012-0106-x
    45 schema:sdDatePublished 2019-04-10T21:39
    46 schema:sdLicense https://scigraph.springernature.com/explorer/license/
    47 schema:sdPublisher N5b5f09090ebd42b0b7c7afb2f9721d29
    48 schema:url http://link.springer.com/10.1007%2Fs12133-012-0106-x
    49 sgo:license sg:explorer/license/
    50 sgo:sdDataset articles
    51 rdf:type schema:ScholarlyArticle
    52 N21a387bd16784252be3b43b643f48a9c schema:name doi
    53 schema:value 10.1007/s12133-012-0106-x
    54 rdf:type schema:PropertyValue
    55 N5b5f09090ebd42b0b7c7afb2f9721d29 schema:name Springer Nature - SN SciGraph project
    56 rdf:type schema:Organization
    57 N65398d13ee804b27b7824aadf9e9bb2d schema:name dimensions_id
    58 schema:value pub.1039875880
    59 rdf:type schema:PropertyValue
    60 N671858891f6e438a8053ae728032614a schema:volumeNumber 14
    61 rdf:type schema:PublicationVolume
    62 N77bd6416f34f48b1a8998a20a77a8629 rdf:first sg:person.016556532267.89
    63 rdf:rest rdf:nil
    64 Nfe5f41cab9134f0ca4ce7f83038e2f6b schema:name readcube_id
    65 schema:value bdf376316c39e9f4f3ea6a8fa998e474fdb831e5d3d54e0465f7c1f188780243
    66 rdf:type schema:PropertyValue
    67 Nffaacf46489a4ca1816cd69414d2532a schema:issueNumber 1
    68 rdf:type schema:PublicationIssue
    69 anzsrc-for:20 schema:inDefinedTermSet anzsrc-for:
    70 schema:name Language, Communication and Culture
    71 rdf:type schema:DefinedTerm
    72 anzsrc-for:2004 schema:inDefinedTermSet anzsrc-for:
    73 schema:name Linguistics
    74 rdf:type schema:DefinedTerm
    75 sg:journal.1145333 schema:issn 1437-2053
    76 1874-6373
    77 schema:name Metaphysica
    78 rdf:type schema:Periodical
    79 sg:person.016556532267.89 schema:affiliation https://www.grid.ac/institutes/grid.7107.1
    80 schema:familyName Berto
    81 schema:givenName Francesco
    82 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/discover/publication?and_facet_researcher=ur.016556532267.89
    83 rdf:type schema:Person
    84 sg:pub.10.1007/978-94-017-1866-0_2 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1037971038
    85 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-017-1866-0_2
    86 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    87 sg:pub.10.1007/bf00693273 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1008754965
    88 https://doi.org/10.1007/bf00693273
    89 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    90 https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511612756 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1098730823
    91 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    92 https://doi.org/10.1080/00048408512341901 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1018084504
    93 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    94 https://doi.org/10.1093/analys/48.4.221 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1059387902
    95 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    96 https://doi.org/10.1093/analys/52.1.12 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1059388074
    97 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    98 https://doi.org/10.1093/analys/57.1.1 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1059388327
    99 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    100 https://doi.org/10.1093/mind/101.401.89 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1059880078
    101 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    102 https://doi.org/10.1093/mind/112.446.195 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1059880993
    103 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    104 https://doi.org/10.1111/0029-4624.00094 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1049926227
    105 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    106 https://doi.org/10.1111/0029-4624.00133 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1042814386
    107 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    108 https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9213.00233 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1050625654
    109 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    110 https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1746-8361.2000.tb00286.x schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1038462270
    111 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    112 https://doi.org/10.2307/2026781 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1069704825
    113 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    114 https://doi.org/10.2307/2183184 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1069812564
    115 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    116 https://doi.org/10.2307/2185716 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1069814689
    117 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    118 https://doi.org/10.2307/2214398 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1069830704
    119 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    120 https://doi.org/10.2307/2219592 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1069834998
    121 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    122 https://doi.org/10.2307/2564596 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1069992958
    123 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    124 https://doi.org/10.2307/2653562 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1070046441
    125 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    126 https://doi.org/10.2307/2940887 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1070140511
    127 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    128 https://doi.org/10.2307/2940990 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1070140550
    129 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    130 https://doi.org/10.2307/3328504 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1070267214
    131 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    132 https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203221303 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1022479024
    133 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    134 https://doi.org/10.5840/monist200083315 schema:sameAs https://app.dimensions.ai/details/publication/pub.1073215605
    135 rdf:type schema:CreativeWork
    136 https://www.grid.ac/institutes/grid.7107.1 schema:alternateName University of Aberdeen
    137 schema:name Department of Philosophy and Northern Institute of Philosophy, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, UK
    138 rdf:type schema:Organization
     




    Preview window. Press ESC to close (or click here)


    ...